> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.annevmuhlethaler.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# On fairness and the practice of authoring ourselves
- URL: https://www.annevmuhlethaler.com/on-fairness-and-the-practice-of-authoring-ourselves/
- Published: 2026-11-21T16:36:19.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T16:36:45.000Z
- Description: Most of us have experienced being underestimated before we've ever said a word. This is the story of the first time I defied the rules, not by reacting but by making a conscious choice grounded in my values.
- Author: Anne V Muhlethaler
- Tags: Essay, Essays, Values, fairness, Authorship, Authority

*Most of us have experienced being underestimated before we've ever said a word. This is the story of the first time I defied the rules, not by reacting but by making a conscious choice grounded in my values. Also, I'm recovering from a bad flu, so no audio with this one, I'll record it as soon as my vocal chords are healed. xx*

---

"I'm so sorry, I'll get the manager to call you back."

I looked up and just about batted my eyelashes at the irate customer who was bending his large frame over the small desk behind which I stood.

"They'd better call back!" he shouted, inches from my face, before turning on his heel and stomping his way across the plush red carpet and out of the door into the crisp autumn afternoon.

I ducked and emitted a deep sigh. A smile formed across my face, and I turned on my own kitten heels to walk down the rugged brown-carpeted stairs to the basement office.

October 2000\. I had taken a job as a shop assistant at a small boutique, a stone's throw from Harrods, in London. I'd arrived in the UK with zero expertise in fashion and a serious enthusiasm for women's footwear. Thankfully, I was fluent in retail, having made assistant manager to the owner of a small chain serving expats' needs while I was meant to be studying in Geneva.

Alone, I collected my thoughts, switched on the electric kettle in the cupboard of a kitchen under the stairs. Whenever I'm overwhelmed, I make myself a mug of tea. The stronger the overwhelm, the higher the likelihood I'll add a big spoonful of honey to my tea alongside a good dollop of milk. That afternoon didn't call for honey.

**I was actually the manager.**

**I just didn't look much like one.**

My dark blonde hair was cropped boy-short at the time, and I wore little to no makeup. Having just turned 25, I likely looked 18 to the angry 40-something man who had just left the boutique under my supervision.

While he was working himself up near boiling point, I had made the decision that there was no point trying to assert my authority in front of someone who'd most likely deny it.

**I would use the ace up my sleeve, my voice.** You see, I may have looked junior, but my deep contralto timbre tells another story. I'd wield it to command the respect I deserved.

After years spent wishing for a higher pitch, dreaming that my vocal cords would one day catch the soaring notes I heard being sung by my favourite singers, **I discovered the unexpected gift of my natural range.**

While I understood it would be hard for this older man to take me, a young-looking woman, seriously, I would easily make myself heard over the phone. There's a natural authority to my tone, which I inherited from my father (I mentioned his booming voice [in a recent essay](https://preview.kit-mail3.com/click/dpheh0hzhmh4/aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuYW5uZXZtdWhsZXRoYWxlci5jb20vbXktYm9keXMtdGFibGUtY2xvdGgtbW9tZW50Lw==?ref=annevmuhlethaler.com)).

There was also the matter of the client's upset.

The owners of the boutique, a franchise of the Christian Louboutin brand at the time, had made it company policy to refuse refunds for goods sold. Instead, they had installed a 12-month, credit-note-only policy, which duly featured on the back of our receipts.

Locking a client into this kind of deal felt wrong to me in all manner of ways. What business refuses a 30-day return on new, unworn product? I asked myself. And, having done my due diligence by scouring the internet, I'd come to believe the policy didn't sit right with UK consumer law.

**That day, I stood in a corner of the basement, dialled the number, and addressed the client, dropping my vocal register a notch.** After a brief introduction, I heard myself telling him: "Yes, of course, I understand, sir," letting him vent before moving to "I'm so sorry, we will absolutely refund you the money."

I heard an audible exhale at the other end. This man had bought a pair of shoes for his wife. What happened between them, I couldn't tell you. That he had been desperate for his money back, however, that was clear.

**That day, I didn't just cover up my identity as a manager to assert my authority in disguise.** I was making space to think things through, before overturning what I deemed to be an unfair policy, one that had no legal grounds. I was part of the leadership of the retailer, yet I identified and empathised with the consumer.

**In hiding for a few moments, I gave myself the agency to make a bold decision as to how to handle this customer query-crisis.**

When my bosses returned, they argued my choice was wrong.

How dare I offer a refund? What precedent was I setting?

They eventually accepted my point of view when I pointed out that a man abusing their staff in full view of other clients and passing traffic on the street wasn't a strong customer acquisition strategy (our boutique was like a fishbowl at the corner of Motcomb and Lowndes Street).

**Part of me wished I'd trusted my voice on the shop floor in front of the customer. But the truth is I needed the space to make a decision that would speak to my values.**

In the moment, I responded as I'd been trained to. A pause was necessary so I could gain the agency to lead with fairness. **This was a muscle I'd never flexed before.** (There are plenty of stories of me defying authority, but in a reactive way, not from a conscious, grounded choice.) **There was a strength there, in that choice to pick fairness over loyalty.**

**Later, I went on to face CEOs and buying directors, editors and stylists in front of whom I still looked like a kid, but I never doubted my voice again.** Nor my ability to defuse a difficult situation, making the right choice for all parties involved.

Today, as a narrative coach and communications expert, I support and guide my clients in finding what values to anchor their communication into, so that they never have to doubt their voices either. I relish seeing them flex their strength. We are all capable of so much more than we think. Including standing up for what we believe in.

Feel free to borrow my stealth mindfulness strategy: finding room to explore what other choices are available to you, especially if you're going to be defying someone, whether that's your bosses or the odds.

**To that man who treated me as if I had no standing, I thank him for the lesson. My strange move protected me from receiving further abuse on the shop floor, and allowed me to use the best tool at my disposal to re-establish my authority.**

Let's look at this word. AUTHOR-ITY.

It's not a word I have used often, yet it points to the real lesson of this story. Not to be courageous (though I was). Not to act fairly (though it's one of my core values). **But the action of pausing and making a conscious choice: responsive, not reactive.**

The word comes from the Latin *auctor*: the originator, the one who makes something grow. In Rome, *auctoritas* wasn't the power a title gives you. It was earned, the weight of having originated something.

That afternoon, my bosses held the power of the policy. What I found in the basement was the other kind: **the authority to originate a different choice, without waiting for anyone's permission.**

We will all face situations where our values will be squeezed by someone else's rule book or policy; situations in which we are underestimated before we've even said a word because of our identity: our age, gender, origin, or status.

Even if we have complied before, that doesn't mean we can't find a way to reclaim our authority, our sense of agency, that will allow us to act from a place of fairness instead of allegiance to an unfair system.

**Those moments when we take a stand, they don't announce themselves. For me, it started with making a cup of builder's tea.**

We may forget those moments, and forget what they prove: our capacity to be bigger than unfair systems, bigger than our conditioning.

That's why authoring yourself is such an important practice, so we don't lose sight of that proof of what we stand for.

So I'll leave you with a question: where are you being asked to choose loyalty over fairness right now, and what would it take to give yourself the pause to author your answer?

PS. I have a brand new (and free) masterclass, AUTHORED, coming up this Monday November 23rd, for women called to lead. **Check it out** [**here**](https://preview.kit-mail3.com/click/dpheh0hzhmh4/aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuYW5uZXZtdWhsZXRoYWxlci5jb20vYXV0aG9yZWQv?ref=annevmuhlethaler.com)**.**